So, I was talking with some friends about cryptids/local legends over the holiday, and I got told a new little gem I hadn’t heard before about a wishing well in Sabattus, Maine.
I found a version online. It’s a short couple of paragraphs, and I’d encourage you to check it out for yourself:
https://92moose.fm/my-picks-for-maines-wildest-urban-legends-that-you-probably-didnt-know
This one hit me hard and lingered. Sort of a portable version of that cold spot in an empty room no one can really explain.
What struck me isn’t the plot itself (it’s short and strange, as many teen-dare stories are), but why it works. Why a single, tiny legend can unsettle me more than an entire horror novel.
Part of it is the image that gets me: a kid being lowered down, the rope slowly unspooling, voices fading, the quiet thickening. The looking up to that tiny circle of light (thanks, ‘The Ring.’) And then the return — someone who looks the same, but not quite.
But it’s strikes deeper than just imagery:
Wells Are Liminal Spaces — and Liminal Spaces Are Always Trouble
Wells sit at that perfect intersection of “ordinary” and “deeply unsettling.” They’re part of everyday life, but also: dark, narrow, echoing, and impossible to see the bottom of
They’re portals — not magical ones, necessarily, but psychological ones. Anything could be down there, and you’d never know until it was too late.
It’s the same energy as cellars, attics, and root cellars that smell like dirt and old secrets. Places we instinctively avoid at night.
The Descent-and-Return Motif is Ancient and Universal
One of the things that makes this legend stick is its universality. Someone goes down into a place they shouldn’t. They come back… changed.
This is a pattern from Greek myths (Orpheus, Persephone), Celtic tales (mound folks), and fairy abduction stories (all over European folklore). It even pulls on the fairy tale string of having a clear warning or moral lesson (for god’s sake, stay away from old wells, they are dangerous).
The Sabattus version is short, but it echoes something very old: that fear that stepping into the wrong place — even on a dare — might expose you to something you aren’t meant to see.
It’s Also Extremely Maine
If you grew up in Maine, you know:
- Forgotten wells are a real and present danger. Every little town has a nearby area where a settlement was started, but didn’t flourish, and many of those now decayed abandoned homesteads from the 1800s have a well concealed on the property. I’m sure there are lots of localized versions of this
- The kids out on their own and playing in the woods is just so tangible. Times have changed, I know, but in rural places, lots of kids probably still spend the whole Sunday summer playing together in the trees. Even if they don’t, we sure did when I was a young ‘un (home before dark was the rule), so it’s highly relatable.
- I think the childhood dare part is universal. It crops up in stories and literature all the time, and a lot of us have experienced it first hand in our youth: running up to slap the haunted house, going into the basement alone with the lights off, climbing a tree higher than we should, saying ‘Bloody Mary’ in the mirror five times.
It’s the perfect storm of rural childhood: boredom, bravado, and a landscape full of places adults warn you to stay away from.
Would I Write a Short Story Inspired by It?
Maybe. It’s easy to see the bones of something there — a fae touch, a trick of time, or an old thing waiting in the dark.
But even if I never do, I love that this tiny sliver of folklore exists at all. Maine is full of these little pockets of weird history and warnings tucked into its forests, lakes, and forgotten corners.
If you know any other local legends like this one, feel free to send them my way. I’m always collecting goosebumps.
Leave a Reply